8

Creative Commons used to publish a license called "Sampling Plus", but according to this page, it was retired/deprecated in 2011 due to inadequate demand and "Not compatible with any other CC license".

Why was this license incompatible with the other CC licenses?

According to the human-readable summary page, the license permits:

  • Creative transformations for commercial and non-commercial uses
  • Verbatim uses for non-commercial uses

With the condition that:

  • You attribute in the manner specified by the author/licensor

At a glance, the freedoms are a mix of NC/ND and the condition is BY. Why is this incompatible with any other CC license? What specific use cases cause it to be incompatible?

4

The Sampling+ license effectively prohibits whole-work derivatives (you can't take a Sampling+ work and incorporate it intact into another work, except in very limited circumstances). This means the license is only partially compatible with the "mainstream licenses" (BY, BY-SA, BY-ND, BY-NC, BY-NC-SA, and BY-NC-ND) -- you need to be careful about how you use the Sampling+ content in the combined work.

Going the other direction:

  • You can't incorporate ShareAlike-licensed content into a Sampling+ work: it introduces an impermissible license restriction to the SA work (incompatible with BY-SA and BY-NC-SA).
  • You can't incorporate NonCommercial content into a Sampling+ work because the Sampling+ license permits commercial use of derivatives (incompatible with BY-NC and BY-NC-SA).
  • You can't incorporate No-Derivatives content in a Sampling+ work for obvious reasons (incompatible with BY-ND and BY-NC-ND).

This leave only one possible way of freely combining a "mainstream license" work with a Sampling+ work: incorporating a CC-BY work into a Sampling+ work. Everything else is restricted or forbidden.

  • 1
    According to this, Sampling+ is incompatible with even CC-BY; is this accurate? – congusbongus Jun 29 '15 at 9:08
  • @congusbongus, if I'm reading it correctly, they're saying that you can use CC-BY in a Sampling+ work, but you can't use Sampling+ in a CC-BY work. – Mark Jun 29 '15 at 9:53

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.