-2

Circa 2006, blogs.sun.com/chandan/entry/copyrights_licenses_and_cddl_illustrated says, in comparing EULA, GPL, CDDL and BSD, that one must "use CDDL for things already under CDDL".

But what does it mean? Aren't you must always use BSD licence for things already under BSD, too? As well as any other licence, as well?

1

CDDL is a weak-copyleft license. Anything that's a derivative of CDDL-licensed works must also be licensed under CDDL. This is in contrast to permissive licenses like BSD; you can derive a BSD-licensed work and license your changes under whatever license you wish, so long as you preserve the copyright notices (including the BSD license text).

Worth noting is how this differs from a strong-copyleft license like the GPL. If you combine a strong-copyleft licensed work with another work, the whole work must be available under the terms of the strong-copyleft license, even if the combined portions are not derivatives of each other.

So to give an example scenario: suppose there's an open source software for making Neapolitan pizzas, free-pizza. You extend (i.e. derive) the library so that it can make ice-cream pizzas, and call it free-icecream-pizza. You then combine it with an unrelated piece of software you wrote that slices circular food of any kind (including cakes and pies), free-food-slicer, to create a combined piece of software that you call free-sliced-icecream-pizza.

  • If free-pizza was permissive (e.g. BSD), you can distribute free-icecream-pizza and free-sliced-icecream-pizza under whatever license you wish, so long as the copyright notices for free-pizza are retained.
  • If free-pizza was weak-copylefted (e.g. CDDL), you must make free-icecream-pizza available under the same license, including when it's combined in free-sliced-icecream-pizza, but the free-food-slicer portion can be whatever license you want.
  • If free-pizza was strong-copylefted (e.g. GPL), all three components - free-pizza, free-icecream-pizza, free-sliced-icecream-pizza - must be available under the strong-copyleft license. You can still distribute the non-free-pizza portions under other licenses, but this must be in addition to the strong-copyleft license.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.